 |
Back in 2005 I started collecting
graphic novels when some of my favorite "Starlord" and "2000AD"
stories from my childhood became available in a collected form.
Since then it has become something of a passion and I am amazed at the
Quality of Graphic novels out there. This page is a catalog of my
current collection which seems to grow at an exponential rate. I used to
write all my reviews in Amazon and then I moved across to the "MySpace"
application "Books I read". I was extremely unhappy to find that about
1/2 of my reviews had disappeared from the I Read application so this
page was born to give me better control. Unfortunately it is going to
take me ages to try to gather together all the missing information so
this page is in a definite state of construction.
Always a WORK IN PROGRESS. PLEASE CHECK BACK
AGAIN SOON. Last Update 7/30/09 |
Index: |
Brian Azzarello |
|
100 Bullets Vol. 1 First Shot,
Last Call |
|
Kurt Busiek |
|
Dave Cooper |
|
Garth Ennis |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Joe Kelly |
|
Robert
Kirkham |
|
Todd
McFarlane |
|
Mike
Mignola |
|
Pat Mills |
|
|
|
|
|
Mark Millar |
|
Allan Moore |
|
|
|
|
Grant Morrison |
|
Simon Oliver |
|
Eric Powell |
|
Jeff Smith |
|
Sam Sarkar |
|
Kevin Smith |
|
Various |
|
|
Brian K Vaughan |
|
|
|
John Wagner |
|
One Of my Favorite Graphic Novels is "303" written by my
Favorite author "Garth Ennis" and illustrated by one of my
favorite artists "Jacen Burrows". This book is an absolute
pleasure to read or even just to look at. Click on the picture
below and buy yourself a copy. You will thank me for it ...I
hope :-) |
 |
Reviews: |
Brian Azzarello |
Title |
100 Bullets Vol. 1 First Shot, Last Call |
ISBN |
ISBN-13: 978-1563896453 |
Author |
Brian Azzarello |
Artists |
Brian Azzarello |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
7 |
I
picked up this book in Borders and started reading it and it
seemed to be an interesting story line. This coupled with the
fact that it was only $10 made me take a chance. I am glad I did
as this is good book that really gets you thinking. The basic
premise is that some sort of government agent approaches people
who have been wronged and offers them a gun with 100 bullets
that are untraceable for them to put things right. Of the three
stories contained in this first book, the first is by far the
best. It is a really good story of gangland Chicago from a
street gangs perspective. Very well drawn and good dialogue
(even if I had no idea what they were saying half the time).
Because it is a Vertigo book the only down side is that it
appears to be printed on toilet paper rather than the glossy
stuff you get from other publishers. |
|
[top] |
|
Garth Ennis |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
One of my all time favorite graphic
novels is "303" which was written by "Garth Ennis" and
illustrated by "Jacen Burrows". How could I not buy "Chronicles
of Wormwood" when the same pair were back together. I am glad to
say I was not disappointed, the artwork in Chronicles is
fantastic and the story is amongst Ennis's best work. Ennis
likes poking fun at religion (the Catholic Faith in particular)
in several of his books but this one is probably the most
extreme. It makes "The Preacher" look a bit tame and not only
includes, offensive drawings, strong language and nudity but it
also has blasphemous story line to seal the deal. I loved it.
There is something about the laid back story telling style that
keeps the whole thing light and amusing (Laugh out loud at
times) rather than offensive. I am not sure what the Vatican
would make of the scene with the Oz pope having a threesome with
three naked nuns.
The story is based around the apocalypse and features all the
parties you would expect but not as you expect to see them. The
Devil is pretty much true to form and both God and his only son
are a bit strange to say the least but what really makes this
story special is the Wormwood himself. His unwillingness to
participate in the end of mankind is the special key to why this
book was such a good read. Jacen Burrows has a unique clean way
of drawing that I really appreciate. I am getting to be a really
big fan of his work. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
This is a pretty good but very short
addition to the chronicles of Wormwood saga. This volume deals
with the popes attempts to capture Jay by using the killer
eunuch. It’s in a similar vein to the first book and the story
is pretty entertaining. There are some funny moments and the
usual amounts of shocking scenes (the fight with the eunuch
springs to mind) but it just doesn’t work as well as the first
book. The artwork is OK but not as good as “Jacen Burrows” work. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
ISBN-13: 978-0785110255 |
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
Darick Robertson |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
A
great prequel to the Punisher series where Garth Ennis explores
Frank Castles Vietnam war history and gives a big hint as to why
The Punisher is such a killing machine. Extremely well written
and illustrated TPB collecting 4 issues of Punisher Born with
some nice extras too. Its message might be a lttle bit
uncomfortable for some but I found it to be a great read and
easily on Par with the rest of the Punisher Max series. In my
childhood I was a big fan of the war comic "Warlord" and I still
have a very soft spot for war stories. I think Garth Ennis
handles this subject very well.
|
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
ISBN-13: 978-0785118404 |
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
Lewis Larosa |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
9 |
Overall |
8 |
The hardcover version of this book
is printed on very high quality paper and as a result of this
the exploding body parts really jump off the page. The book
contains two story arcs, "In the Beginning" and "Kitchen Irish".
I found both stories very engaging and would find it hard to
choose a favorite. The quality of illustration is very good and
the violence is off the scale. I don’t think I have ever seen so
many brutal killings in one book. It is all done with a subtle
dark sense of humor and references to real world events. The
dialogue is also very well done but definitely not for children.
This book is highly recommended if you can stomach the violence.
|
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
ISBN-13: 978-0785120223 |
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
Dougie Braithwaite, Leandro Fernandez |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
8 |
Collects Punisher Max Vol. 3: Mother Russia and Punisher Max
Vol. 4: Up Is Down And Black Is White.
In Mother Russia, The punisher is forced into a suicide mission
deep inside Russia with the goal to retrieve a deadly
retrovirus. This story is full of the graphic violence and
action the punisher series is famous for but this time with a
slightly more military bent. The artwork is pretty good and
really stands out on the premium paper. Fantastic tale with many
subplots and twists to keep the reader hooked. The dialogue and
level of violence are off the scale and quite a few scenes have
jaw dropping politically incorrect references. I really enjoyed
this story. It is probably my favorite Punisher book to date.
Up is down and Black is White is a mafia based tale based
around evil mafia mobster Nicky Cavella who finally figures out
what is required to send Frank Castle over the edge (he
desecrates his family's grave). The violence that ensues is even
shocking for the Punisher and it is an absolute bloodfest. The
language and situations are very adult orientated and some of
the flashbacks to fill in the background on main characters such
as Nicky Cavella are particularly shocking. Highly recommended
read for adult audiences only. Artwork is not bad but nothing
really special. Collects Punisher #13-24.
|
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
ISBN-13: 978-0785128670 |
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
Lan
Medina |
Ratings |
Story |
8* |
Art |
9 |
Overall |
8 |
This hardback collects the two stories “Man of Stone” and “Widowmaker”.
The quality of the paper in this collection is excellent and the
images really jump off the page. “Man of Stone” is a compelling
story with strong dialogue and great artwork. The main focus of
the story is the punisher vs a barbaric Russian general. This is
one of the best books I have read this year. The second story
“Widowmaker” took me a while to get into but it had a satisfying
conclusion. This was a very violent story of female revenge and
featured a female punisher. Definitely not as good as “Man of
Stone”. Artwork was very good.
*Man of Stone is a
9+ |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
"The Preacher " is a fantastic piece of work from the master of
shock himself (Garth Ennis). Like all his books I have read so
far this one has captivating and thought provoking story lines
and witty well written dialogue. There is plenty to offend a lot
of people but nothing too over the top in the bad language and
gore departments. The artwork is well done and fits the story
well. For once this is a book that lives up to all the hype. I
can't wait to read the next installment. I reckon if you enjoyed
the TV series Carnivale you will enjoy this book. The Preacher
Volume 1 is a highly recommended read for adults only so don't
buy it for little Timmy or he may have nightmares :-) |
|
[top] |
Title |
Until the end of the World |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
Steve Dillon |
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
Fantastic story and great
artwork. Another one of Garth Ennis's finest works and IMHO
better than the first part. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
Yet Another fantastic addition to
the preacher series that is showing absolutely no sign of losing
momentum. This may very well be the best book in the series yet.
The art is good and the story is very well written although
there does seem to be some erosion in the level of detail in the
pictures as the series goes on. I had a great deal of difficulty
putting this book down once I started. It has to be noted that
the quality of paper in this version isn’t as good as the
previous two. For mature readers only. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
This book is a collection of 3 back
stories covering some of the characters in the Preacher series.
The first story is an absolute classic and it covers the bizarre
history of the Saint of Sinners. Although the artwork does vary
between artists in this tale the overall effect is very good
indeed. Superb! The second tale I enjoyed less and it fills in
the back story for Ar*e face. The style and content of this
little tale doesn’t really seem to fit in well with the rest of
the Preacher series although it is still pretty violent and
shocking. Ar*e face himself doesn’t look as grotesque as he did
in the Preacher books. The final tale covers the insane Good Old
Boys Jody and T.C. in a ultra violent side story. The art work
and storytelling are fantastic and these guys really deserve
their own book. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
Review AWOL |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
Review AWOL |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
I really enjoyed the first two books
in this series so I had high hopes for part 3. It is nearly a
year since I read part 2 so when I started reading this book I
found myself a little confused with the storyline and
characters. This is a really good book and has some very funny
(not politically correct) moments. It is as good as the first
two books but took a while to get going. Ennis takes a very
risky storyline in this issue (think 911) but manages to pull it
off with some excellent political satire. This book does a good
job of fleshing out Wee Hughie and explaining the superhero back
story. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
I was drawn to this book because I
am a great fan of carlos Ezquerra's earlier 2000AD work. I was
very pleasantly surprised to find a good story, excellent art
and some truly laugh out loud funny bits. This book permeates a
kind of dry sarcastic humor that is so prevalent in the UK. "A
man Called Kev" ties up the story from "The Authority KEV" and
it is more of an urban war story than the superhero stuff in the
earlier book. The art is very much in the style of 2000AD
instead of some of the glossy "SPAWN" type detailed stuff but it
fits the story perfectly.
Be warned that its is not a "politically correct" book and may
offend various groups. It is the most enjoyable book I have read
in a long while. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
I think this book will polarize many
people. It probably wont appeal to the hardcore superhero marvel
and DC comic book readers but it may well appeal to some of the
old school 2000AD, Starlord types. Up front I have to say I fall
into the latter category and I have never really been into
Batman, Superman, Spider man etc. I grew up on a diet of Judge
Dredd, Strontium Dog, Robohunter, ABC warriors etc. This book
feels like an adult progression of those days so perhaps this is
a comic book that appeals to a limited demographic?
The book is a strange mix of gritty British sarcastic humor and
over the top alien superhero stuff. I think the SAS stuff works
well and the Alien stuff less so. I found it to be an enjoyable
read with art that is both clean and appropriate. It is horribly
politically incorrect and contains scenes of gore and nudity in
profusion but that didn't bother me.
I dont think it works quite as well as the follow on book "A Man
Called KEV" but I still found it an enjoyable read. It hasnt
made me want to try out any of the authority books. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
I really enjoyed the previous two
books in the Kev series. I found them to be laugh out loud funny
and although much of the material could be viewed as offensive
it really seemed to work in the context it was used. The third
book is probably the weakest in the series and has less funny
moments but it is still definitely worth a read.
What this book does is flesh out the Kev story and bring it to a
satisfying close. The story keeps your attention and has
satisfying plot twists and surprises. It continues the very
anti-establishment focus of the first two novels but
concentrates more on the bad treatment of the SAS. The artwork
by Carlos Ezquerra is great as usual and the "Alien" based dream
Kev has at the beginning of the book has a very "Strontium Dog"
look to it. I think the bad language might be a little overdone
but this is a minor criticism. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
This is one of Garth Ennis's best
novels. I found this a very enjoyable read and in my opinion the
artwork is fantastic. The story is well written and thought
provoking and the art style fits it perfectly. The book is a
little short but it makes up for it with a really good ending.
Not as light hearted as much of Ennis's work but none the worse
for this. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
This is not a particularly long or a
thought provoking read. The art is OK but ultimately this is a
bit of pulp fiction with shock value thrown in to appeal to a
teenage male audience. This isn't one of
Ennis's best bits of work but it isn't bad
for a comic book and it has its funny
moments. The Kev series works much better
than this. If you came to this book because
you like the preacher you may well be
disappointed. |
|
[top] |
Title |
Pride and Joy |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Garth Ennis |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
A great Garth Ennis novel with a more serious tone than his
usual stuff. The art work fits the story perfectly and it
is the first book I have read that has been illustrated by John
Higgins. Highly recommended. |
|
[top] |
|
[top] |
|
[top] |
|
[top] |
|
[top] |
Dave Cooper |
Title |
Suckle the Status Of Basil |
ISBN |
1-56097-301-3 |
Author |
Dave
Cooper |
Artists |
Dave Cooper |
Ratings |
Story |
6 |
Art |
6 |
Overall |
6 |
One of the weirdest books I have read in a long time. A very
strange and whimsical book that is more than a little erotic.
Nicely bound and presented too. For Mature Readers only. |
|
[top] |
Mike Mignola |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Mike
Mignolia |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
I have always been put off trying out the
Hellboy books by the rather simplistic art but I do like the
movies. When a chance to purchase the library edition came up at
an amazing price I decided to take the plunge. I am glad I did
as once you start to read the books the art fits the story
perfectly. The art in this huge format library edition in
particular looks fantastic. The first story “Seed of
destruction” is a great read and it introduces many of the
characters I recognize from the movies. The second part “Wake
the Devil” continues on with the interesting Ragna RoK Nazi
supernatural theme and hammers home the fact I was so wrong to
dismiss these books in the past. Minola does a superb job of
creating a sense of suspense and horror in these tales. The
extras in this book are also top notch. |
|
[top] |
Pat Mills |
Title |
The
Complete
Nemesis the
Warlock
Volume 1 |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Pat Mills |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
7 |
This one
really takes
me back to
early
2000AD. The
smaller
print format
can make
some of the
complex
drawings
difficult to
view. They
certainly
seem more
cluttered
than I
remember
first time
round but my
eyesight
isn't what
it used to
be.
|
|
[top] |
Title |
Charley's War: 2
June - 1 August 1916 |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Pat Mills |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
9 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
8 |
I
was a big reader of war comics as a child but I read
"Warlord" and not "Battle" where Charley's war was first
published. I am also a big fan of Pat Mills as he penned
some of my all time favorite comic strips such as Ro-busters
and ABC warriors. I decided to buy this hardback version of
Charley's war as Amazon.co.uk was selling them very cheaply.
I particularly enjoyed the extras in the book with
interviews, timelines, real history and background stories.
The artwork is very faithful to the old comic book originals
and as such fairly low tech but it fits the subject matter
so well. The story is engaging and very though provoking
especially as Pat Mills went through huge amounts of
research to keep it authentic. I would even go as far as
saying the book is moving in a way few comic strips can hope
to achieve. Highly recommended. |
|
[top] |
Title |
ABC Warriors: Hellbringer |
ISBN |
905437560 |
Author |
Pat Mills |
Artists |
Tony Skinner – Kev Walker |
Ratings |
Story |
5 |
Art |
5 |
Overall |
5 |
Although I was a big fan of Robusters I didn't enjoy the spin off
series "ABC warriors" Quite as much. That's not to say I didnt enjoy
ABC warriors but just that some of the characters were not as
compelling. Hellbringer is a very colorful graphic novel but I find
the artwork a bit cluttered and confusing at times. I also didn't
like the way Hammerstein and Ro- Jaws were drawn. The story is OK
but the highlight of the book is the short bonus story at the end. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Pat Mills |
Artists |
Clint Langley |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
I used to
read Slaine many years ago in 2000AD but it never looked like
this. The artwork in this book is very detailed, colorful and
unusual. Apparently Clint uses a combination of conventional art
and digital manipulation to achieve the lush and often bizarre
pictures. What you end up with is a comic strip with art quality
and detail that would normally only be reserved for cover art.
The two stories in this book are both very enjoyable and
extremely violent. Classic Pat Mills work with grotesque
characters and situations. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Pat Mills |
Artists |
Clint Langley |
Ratings |
Story |
6 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
The second collection picks up nicely from where Volume One left
off and it includes Books 3 and 4 of the Books of Invasions.
Another well written and easy to read story with visually
stunning art that is especially impressive on the monsters. Like
the first two books there is plenty of gore and nudity but it is
all tastefully done. Despite the unbelievably high quality art
in the Book of Invasion series one thing has started to irritate
me a bit while reading them. The faces of the characters in the
book often don’t have appropriate expressions for the action or
dialogue and they seem to be looking in random directions rather
than at whatever the particular frame is concentrating on. In
some ways it reminds me of those cheezy photo love stories you
used to see in comics in the 70's where the pictures and actors
impressions never quite seemed to match the subject of the
frame. Its only a minor niggle however and no doubt it is a by
product of the digital manipulation. I reckon if you were to
look carefully at the book you would find that the facial art is
re-used a lot. It’s the only possible way Langley can maintain
this level of detail otherwise each frame would take many many
hours to draw. Special mention has to go to the Bonus Covers
section of this volume where the art is absolutely stunning. |
|
[top] |
Title |
Slaine: The Books of Invasions: Volume 3 |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Pat Mills |
Artists |
Clint Langley |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
9 |
Overall |
8 |
The third volume in the stunning “Books
of Invasions” series collects books 5 and 6. The standard of
artwork is again fantastic and the stories are top notch too. I
really enjoyed both the books. The first book “Odacon” is a very
satisfying conclusion to the battle with his adversaries and
ends with Slaine
setting off to look for his son. Slaine finds his son working in a
freak show in the second book “Carnival”. The story in this book is
a bit of a departure from the other books in that it takes the form
of a bit of a murder mystery. The story and artwork in this story
are probably the best in the series. |
|
[top] |
Title |
Complete
Robusters |
ISBN |
978-1-905437-82-5 |
Author |
Pat Mills |
Artists |
Various |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
8 |
I used to
read Slaine many years ago in 2000AD but it never looked like
this. The artwork in this book is very detailed, colorful and
unusual. Apparently Clint uses a combination of conventional art
and digital manipulation to achieve the lush and often bizarre
pictures. What you end up with is a comic strip with art quality
and detail that would normally only be reserved for cover art.
The two stories in this book are both very enjoyable and
extremely violent. Classic Pat Mills work with grotesque
characters and situations. |
|
[top] |
Kevin Smith |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Kevin Smith |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
5 |
Art |
5 |
Overall |
5 |
I am a big fan of the Jay and
Silent Bob movies and some of the same style of humor comes
across here. A good book for Kevin Smith fans. |
|
[top] |
Allan Moore |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Allan Moore |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
7 |
It took me a while to get into this
book. For the first two chapters I was less than impressed by
what seemed a genereric superhero story but from chapter 3
onwards the interesting story lines and subplots really began to
grab my attention. The characters are pretty strange but Moore
develops them nicely as the book goes on and this really is a
satisfying read.
The artwork within the book is good although the quality of the
paper could be better. There is a lot of things going on in the
frames and it is worth a second read to pick out some of the
funny things going on in the background.
This book is definitely recommended for Moore fans. A lighter
read than "The Watchmen" but none the worse for that.
|
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Allan Moore |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
7 |
I really enjoyed book one and this
book continued to impress. Moore does an excellent job of
developing the characters from the first book and adds a few new
ones to the mix. The most enjoyable of the new characters is
officer Joe PI who is a robot with a sense of humor. Joe PI
integrates very nicely with the old team and generates some good
story lines and one liners. The plots in book two are as good if
not better than the first collection.
There are tons of things going on on every page (many of them
you will miss on the first read) but the book never becomes a
chore to read. Highly recommended but you must read book one
first. |
|
[top] |
Title |
Tom Strong (Book
1) |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Allan Moore |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
I really enjoyed book one and this
book continued to impress. Moore does an excellent job of
developing the characters from the first book and adds a few new
ones to the mix. The most enjoyable of the new characters is
officer Joe PI who is a robot with a sense of humor. Joe PI
integrates very nicely with the old team and generates some good
story lines and one liners. The plots in book two are as good if
not better than the first collection.
There are tons of things going on on every page (many of them
you will miss on the first read) but the book never becomes a
chore to read. Highly recommended but you must read book one
first. |
|
[top] |
Title |
The Watchmen |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Allan Moore |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
Review AWOL |
|
[top] |
|
[top] |
|
[top] |
Title |
The League
Of Extraordinary Gentlemen Vol 3 |
ISBN |
ISBN-13: 978-1401217105 |
Author |
Allan Moore |
Artists |
Kevin O'Neill |
Ratings |
Story |
4 |
Art |
6 |
Overall |
5 |
[The League of
Extraordinary Gentlemen Black Dossier - Hardcover] -
This book reminds me of annuals I used to read as a child. It
has a mixture of Graphic novel sections to narrate the story and
some lengthy prose sections to represent the "Black Dossier"
itself. Although the book is well written and nicely laid out
with different textures of papers and such I did not really
enjoy it that much. Some of the semi erotic art work is
particularly well done but the prose sections just drag for me.
Even the back story just doesn't seem to have any drive or edge
to it and the prose sections really disrupt the flow. Some
sections are quite enjoyable such as the interplay with Jimmy
Bond and the Bertie Wooster story but other sections are
incredibly hard work. The “Crazy Wide Forever” story is
virtually unreadable. The 3D section looks pretty impressive but
does not provide a very satisfying end to the affair. Reading
this book has been more of a chore than a pleasure especially
when the characters are speaking in strange tongues. |
|
[top] |
John Wagner |
Title |
Robo-Hunter: Day of
the Droids |
ISBN |
|
Author |
John Wagner |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
10 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
9 |
favorite comic book
story of all time. Excellent writing and great artwork still
feels as fresh as when I first read it back in 2000AD. |
|
[top] |
Mark Millar |
Title |
Wanted |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Mark Millar
|
Artists |
J.G. Jones & Paul Mounts |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
Excellent artwork and story. Wanted is a
very violent book with a somewhat controversial ending. I think
if you enjoy stuff like Punisher Max you will probably enjoy
this although there isn’t much in the way of a moral code.
Extras are pretty good too. |
|
[top] |
Joe Kelly |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Joe Kelly |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
5 |
Art |
6 |
Overall |
6 |
This is a very challenging
book to read and definitely not for everyone. The art work is
beautifully colored and drawn but often the way it is laid out
makes it very confusing. The script is also very disjointed and
hard to follow. The first few chapters gave me a headache and
left me wondering if this was art for arts sake. By Chapter 3
some of the threads of story started to make some kind of sense
but it was still the sort of book you have to lock yourself away
in a quiet room to have any chance of following. Does a graphic
novel have to be this frustrating just so hardened comic book
readers have a sense of superiority over the more casual reader?
Chapter 5 rounded things off nicely although I still found some
of the pictures hard to follow (so busy and full of detail).
Some great art work and sense of achievement in finishing this
novel but I don’t think I will be buying the sequel. |
|
[top] |
Simon Oliver |
Title |
100 Bullets Vol. 1 First Shot, Last Call |
ISBN |
ISBN -4012-1064-3
|
Author |
Simon
Oliver |
Artists |
Tony
Moore |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
7 |
The book is set in a not very nice part of LA where pests, evil
landlords and drug pushers rule the roost and poor people
suffer. Our hero is an ex con who is now working as a pest
exterminator. Unfortunately the pests are fighting back and his
colleagues seem to be just as dangerous. This is an extremely
well written book that is full of adult themes and great
atmospheric art. Not a book for the squeamish or younger readers
but a very intriguing mature read. The main plot twists around
and opens up new clues and story lines at a fair old rate. I am
hooked and will be out to buy book 2 to find out just what the
significance of that scarab really is. Good value too.
|
|
[top] |
Grant Morrison |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Grant Morrison |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
I picked up this book because
I was intrigued by the concept and
very impressed by the art. This is definitely a Bizarre book
that I struggled to follow. Some of the story arcs are fairly
straightforward but generally speaking it is so surreal and at
times confusing that it can be hard going. On the other hand the
artwork is fantastic and there are glimmers of genius in some of
the story. It certainly makes you think and probably needs a few
reads to sink in. It contains some pretty adult themes, concepts
and strong language. |
|
[top] |
Eric
Powell |
Title |
The Goon
Volume 1: Nothin' But Misery |
ISBN |
978-1569719985 |
Author |
Eric
Powell |
Artists |
Eric
Powell |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
The Goon is a kind of anti hero
mobster set somewhere back in the 40’s or 50’s in a land
infested by all sorts of Zombies and other strange creatures.
It’s a comic book version of a cult B movie. The artwork is
consistently excellent and the stories are funny and well
written. I was especially impressed by the way the pencil
drawings are used to show flash backs. |
|
[top] |
Title |
The Goon
Volume 2: My Murderous Childhood |
ISBN |
978-1-59307-109-7 |
Author |
Eric
Powell |
Artists |
Eric
Powell |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
Volume 2 was
as good if not better than the first volume and does a great Job
of filling in the back story for the characters. A highly
recommended read. |
|
[top] |
Title |
The Goon
Volume 3:
Heaps of
Ruination |
ISBN |
978-1593072926 |
Author |
Eric
Powell |
Artists |
Eric
Powell |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
9 |
Overall |
8 |
Another classic
collection of goon stories with witty dialogue and great
artwork. If you enjoyed the first two books you will love this.
The Hellboy Crossover story is a special treat. |
|
[top] |
Title |
The Goon
Volume 4:
Virtue and the Grim Consequences Thereof |
ISBN |
978-1593074562 |
Author |
Eric
Powell |
Artists |
Eric
Powell |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
Another classic edition to the Goon series with fantastic
artwork and great stories. The level of humor is absolutely spot
on and if you like the previous 3 books you will love this one.
I particularly enjoyed the "Fish Canners" story. |
|
[top] |
Title |
The Goon
Volume 5: Wicked Inclinations |
ISBN |
978-1593076467 |
Author |
Eric
Powell |
Artists |
Eric
Powell |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
The Goon series shows no sign of losing momentum. The artwork is
still fantastic and the humor keeps a nice balance of slapstick
and macabre. If you enjoyed the previous 4 books you will love this one.
The only part I was not so keen on were the bonus short stories
that were not up to the books usual standards. |
|
[top] |
Robert Kirkman |
Title |
The Walking Dead Volume 3: Safety Behind Bars |
ISBN |
|
Author |
|
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
|
Art |
|
Overall |
|
This series of Graphic novels has the
strange distinction that it is the only one that my wife has
ever read and really enjoyed. If you liked the first two books
buying this one is a no brainer. Book 3 is a very addictive read
and it is hard to put down when you start. It expands the plot
line nicely and seems to have more action and less relationship
based story lines. |
|
[top] |
Brian K Vaughan |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
978-1582405728 |
Author |
Brian K Vaughan |
Artists |
Moore, Staples |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
I really enjoyed this book
even though it could be considered quite offensive. Just like
the great religious parodies “Life of Brian” and “Dogma” it
pokes a bit of fun at organized religion but does so in a light
hearted slapstick way. This color version of the collected books
1 to 4 is gorgeous to look at and the drawing is excellent. The
script is fun and witty and the action never lets up. If I can
make one criticism it is that the book is a little short. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
978-1-58240-652-7 |
Author |
Brian K Vaughan |
Artists |
Roberts, Moore, Staples |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
Battle Pope is lewd, Crude and
offensive. It is also pretty funny and a very entertaining read
even if you are a Catholic. The artwork fits the story perfectly
and the large list of characters are superbly drawn. Battle Pope
is like a comedy punisher with an over active sex drive. His
partner who also happens to be the son of God is a meek and mild
Hippy type that is apparently hung like a grand national winner.
Volume two is as good as the first Volume and that makes it a
great read. If you are sensitive and easily offended please stay
away but for us hardy types it's a great way to while away an
hour. Extras are pretty good too. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
978-1-58240-677-0 |
Author |
Brian K Vaughan |
Artists |
Roberts, Walker, Su, Moore, Staples |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
The third volume in the Battle Pope Series is as good as the first
two volumes. It is still just as offensive and funny and the art is
spot on. This volume introduces Santa and Mary as new characters to
great effect. Mr. Vaughan is overdue a visit from the Spanish
Inquisition I think :-).Definitely not recommended for sensitive
religious types. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
978-1-58240-751-7 |
Author |
Brian K Vaughan |
Artists |
Moore, Staples |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
The final book in the series follows on
in the same vein with its crude and funny style. In this book
Battle Pope ends up fighting with God himself which is pretty
Bizarre. A very enjoyable series. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Brian K Vaughan |
Artists |
Niko
Henrichon |
Ratings |
Story |
4 |
Art |
10 |
Overall |
5 |
If you
read the reviews on the back cover you would expect this to be
one of the greatest comic books ever written but I found it to
be quite unsatisfying. The story feels very one dimensional
without any subtle counterplots to keep your interest and it is
also very short. I have nothing against animal stories, try the
work of William Horwood for some excellent examples of the
genre, but this just feels like Disney with shock value to me.
It even has the formulaic Disney cute cub character. On the
other hand the artwork is a pleasure to behold. Every page is
filled with glorious images and a very atmospheric color
palette.
Ultimately this book is very pretty to look at but it nothing
special to read. If you like Disney movies but would like to see
some more gore then this may be the book for you. |
|
[top] |
Sam Sarkar |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Sam Sarkar |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
7 |
Overall |
7 |
I bought this book because I was impressed
with artwork , thought the premise of the story was interesting
and mainly because it was on sale for only $10 in hardcover. The
story was pretty good but I found it very difficult to tell the
characters apart as they all looked pretty similar. All in all a
very stylish book but a bit weak on script. |
|
[top] |
Kurt Busiek |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Kurt Busiek |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
I really enjoyed this book. The story was
well written and it captured Conan perfectly. The artwork was
beautifully colored and a pleasure to look at. It is done
without bold inks so the images have a bit of a water color look
to them. At first I found them to look a little lacking in
detail but I soon warmed to the lush style. Nice biography of
Howard at the end too. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Kurt Busiek |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
9 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
8 |
There are
many Graphical novels that are quite a challenge to read. They
often have confusing cluttered art work and convoluted story
lines. This is not one of them. Conan, God In The Bowl is a
straight forward classic adventure tale with a bit of murder
mystery thrown in for good measure. The artwork is perfectly
suited to the subject matter and great to look at. The character
of Conan is built up nicely from the first volume and I found it
difficult to put the book down once I started. |
|
[top] |
Jeff Smith |
|
[top] |
Todd McFarlane |
Title |
Spawn
Collection, Vol. 1 |
ISBN |
|
Author |
Todd McFarlane |
Artists |
|
Ratings |
Story |
9 |
Art |
9 |
Overall |
9 |
I really enjoyed this book. The story was
well written and it captured Conan perfectly. The artwork was
beautifully colored and a pleasure to look at. It is done
without bold inks so the images have a bit of a water color look
to them. At first I found them to look a little lacking in
detail but I soon warmed to the lush style. Nice biography of
Howard at the end too. |
|
[top] |
Various |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Various |
Artists |
Various |
Ratings |
Story |
n/a |
Art |
n/a |
Overall |
n/a |
The concept here is a book
containing the first issue from seven series to whet your
appetite. (DMZ) : Good Art and an intriguing story line. I might
give this a try in the future especially if an omnibus edition
gets published. (Army@Love) : Nice art work but I couldn’t get
into the story. A little too farfetched even for me. (Jack of
Fables) : Good artwork and the promise of an interesting story
line. I might check this one out further. (The Exterminators): I
really enjoyed this story and was impressed by the art and the
writing. Definite buy. (Scalped): A very dark and gritty Native
American based gangster tale. Not bad but pretty heavy going.
(Crossing Midnight): A very intriguing story line and good art.
I don’t really like books with kids as the heroes so I am
unlikely to buy this one. (Loveless): A western tale that
strangely left me cold. |
|
[top] |
Title |
DC/Top Cow Crossovers |
ISBN |
978-1401213381 |
Author |
Various |
Artists |
Various |
Ratings |
Story |
6 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
6 |
A collection of crossovers between the stars of DC and the stars
of Top Cow. #1: Darkness/ Batman was a must read for me as it
filled in a few blanks the Darkness Omnibus I read recently.
This is the first Batman I have read in about 20 years and I
actually enjoyed it although it did feel to me as if they were
throwing in characters just for the sake of it. #2: Witchblade/JLA.
Not a bad story but a little confusing and techy at the start. I
am not a big fan of JLA and think the whole thing is a little
pointless. A bit like using a 20,000 pound hydraulic press to
crack a walnut. #3: Darkness/ Superman. I really enjoyed this
story of Ecstacado trying to become the mob lord of Metropolis.
I am not a big superman fan but this was definitely one of the
better crossovers. The pacing was good and it filled in some
more blanks for me in the Darkness story. Art was pretty good
too. #4: JLA/ Cyberforce. I am not familiar with Cyberforce at
all but found this story to be enjoyable if a little formulaic.
Why is it in every story featuring superman they have to make
him vulnerable in some way regardless of who his adversary is?
Artwork was pretty good in this tale too. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Various |
Artists |
Various |
Ratings |
Story |
7 |
Art |
8 |
Overall |
7 |
When I first started reading this
book I was in a state of confusion. All the characters and names
thrown at me were bewildering. I suppose long time fans of DC
could make sense of what was going on . I was seriously
wondering if I had made a huge mistake buying all four books at
once. The more I read the more things started to fall into place
and the more I began to enjoy the book. By the end I couldn't wait to start
book 2. The artwork is very good in typical
superhero fashion. I also found the
discussion sections between each week to be
a much better than average read. Summary: A
hard book for non DC fans at first but
ending up a very enjoyable read. Great
artwork and paper. |
|
[top] |
Title |
|
ISBN |
|
Author |
Various |
Artists |
Various |
Ratings |
Story |
8 |
Art |
9 |
Overall |
8 |
This is a hefty monster of a book (1280
pages) that is almost too heavy to read comfortably in bed. The
artwork is vibrant and although I don’t normally read this type
of mainstream graphic novel I was intrigued enough by the Garth
Ennis connection to give it a go. There are times when the story
arcs can be a little bit confusing (story probably running in
parallel with Witchblade) but it is generally an easy read. Some
of the double page spreads can be physically hard to read
especially if you are like me and don’t want to damage the books
spine. I didn’t enjoy the “Tales of the Darkness” stories as
much but the preview of volume 2 was right back on form. |
|
[top] |
[Back to
"BooksnStuff" home] |
All material Copyright ZENSURWEB 2009

"One Mad Dog and his Master" |